One of the reasons I love Carnivale is the endless speculation that ensues whenever Arin and I watch it. Every week we come up with or refine a previous week's hypothesis as to what the hell (no pun intended) this show is about, and what does it all mean? But this week, the following observation was made: Carnivale and Star Wars simply have too much in common. Consider the following...
Henry Scudder is Darth Vader
Since much of this is based upon a family tree that is slowly emerging, let's start by making the assumption that Henry Scudder is analogous to Darth Vader. And what can we base this on? Well, for starters they they are both incredibly evil. At least they appear to be. If this Star Wars theory holds water than I believe one day we will see that Scudder was simply corrupted, but will prove to be good at heart. Scudder of course, also used to belong to a rare and highly secretive group called the Knight Templars. The Knight Templars.
Ben Hawkins is Luke Skywalker
Unlike Scudder, he is good. But more importantly, Ben Hawkins in Henry Scudder's son. He is also a young man coming into a incredible power bestowed upon because of exceptionally gifted father.
Sofie is Princess Leia
In one episode last season, we saw that Sofie's mother Apollonia was raped by Henry Scudder, thus making Ben Hawkins her brother. A half brother, yes, but a brother nonetheless. This helps to reinforce a rather weird chemistry between her and Ben, a relationship that at first seemed destined to be romantic, but as the story evolves is much deeper than that. She too has an incredible power, no doubt passed onto her by her father.
Clayton Jones is Han Solo
You get the sense that Sofie and Clayton are made for each other, the way Han and Leia were made for each other. They clearly care for one another, by both are simply too stubborn to say it. Second, he is a total cowboy who is genuine and kind, but doesn't like to play by the rules. Plus, Tim DeKay kind of looks like Harrison Ford. What more proof do you need?
Samson is Obi Wan
Don't be lured to think that just because Samson is a really weird short guy that he must therefore be Yoda. That would be too obvious; but I admit it, that was my first conclusion as well. But when you think about it, it starts to make sense, consider that Samson and Scudder used to work together, and they were arguably very close. Samson is also an important messenger, and teacher for Ben who is learning how to wield a special power for the first time. But Yoda was all of these things for Luke Skywalker as well, but to me, Samson does not appear to be the "master" that management seems to be. Which is why of course that...
Management is Yoda
Aside from being incredibly cryptic and the one who holds all the secrets to Ben's Family Tree, he is also the guardian of a very important prophecy. A prophecy about a battle between good and evil. He once played a part in this prophecy, but his time has passed, and it is time for the next generation to take over. Furthermore, by all appearances he is not one you might fear - assuming of course we ever do actually see him - given that he is apparently old and crippled. But underneath the surface is arguably one of the most powerful people on the show.
Varyln Stroud is Boba Fett
A bounty hunter of sorts looking to find a capture Ben Hawkins, preferably alive.
Of course, the analogy is not bullet proof. There are many holes in the theory, and many characters who don't fit into the parallel as well as I would like... take the following characters for example:
- Brother Justin Crowe
- Iris Crowe
- Stumpy and Rita Sue
- Libby
- Lodz - Darth Maul? After all he was killed by Samson/Obi-Wan
- Lila
- Ruthie and Gabriel
I am not purporting that Star Wars was the genesis of the motifs in Carnivale, certainly not; or that Carnivale was purposely made to parallel Star Wars. But being both stories about the battle between good and evil, they do seem to share a lot of similarities.
Or is my long time Star Wars bias simply clouding my judgment?
Recent Comments